- Reviews
We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content.
Keep Your Tot Cozy With the Best Fitted Crib Sheets
As a parent, it’s important to make sure your baby has a safe and comfortable sleeping environment, and that starts with the mattress. But what would a mattress be without the perfect fitted sheet? Whether you’re a first-time parent or a seasoned caregiver, you know how important it is to have the right crib sheets to keep your little one comfortable and safe.
But with so many options on the market, finding the right type of crib sheet can be an overwhelming task. We’ve rated and reviewed some of the top-rated fitted crib sheets of 2023 to help you pick the comfiest option, so you can feel confident that your baby is sleeping safe and sound.
Buying Guide: Fitted Crib Sheets
Having a comfortable and safe sleep environment for your baby is vital for their development and for your peace of mind. When it comes to outfitting a crib, it’s hard to beat the convenience of a fitted crib sheet. But they come in all shapes and sizes, making it hard to know which ones are right for your baby. We’ve put together this comprehensive buying guide to help you pick the perfect fitted crib sheet for your little one.
Considerations for Choosing a Quality Fitted Crib Sheet
Material
Softness and breathability are important factors to consider when choosing a fitted crib sheet. So, look for lightweight and breathable materials, such as cotton or bamboo, and durable enough to stand up to multiple uses.
You should check the fabric label for details on how the material should be cared for and washed, as some materials require special treatment to maintain their softness and prevent fading. Additionally, look for formaldehyde-free and flame-retardant materials, as this helps ensure safety.
Size
Fitted crib sheets should fit tightly over the crib mattress and stay in place securely. To ensure a snug fit, measure the crib mattress and ensure that any sheets you purchase accurately match that size. Make sure to avoid tassels or dangling ribbons that could pose a strangulation hazard.
Durability
Choose sheets with strong stitching, seams, and elastic bands to ensure they’ll last through multiple uses. Invest in high-quality fabrics over low-cost options to get the best value in terms of durability. Additionally, if you’re buying sheets from an online source, check customer reviews for feedback on how well the sheets hold up over time.
Color
Crib sheets come in a variety of colors and patterns, so choose one that matches your nursery décor or complements it nicely. Consider purchasing two or three sets of sheets, as babies often make messes requiring more frequent washing than adults’ bedding.
Breathability
For added comfort, while sleeping, look for fabrics with good breathability ratings. It’s better to opt for materials through which air can flow freely between fibers to help regulate body temperature and keep your baby cool throughout the night. Popular fabrics known for their breathability are bamboo, organic cotton, and microfiber fabrics. Look for cotton muslin or bamboo fabrics, which are lightweight yet absorbent enough to wick away moisture during summer and provide warmth during winter nights.
Hypoallergenic
Especially important for babies with sensitive skin, choose hypoallergenic sheets made from fabrics free from chemicals and irritants. Opt for fitted crib sheets that don’t contain latex, phthalates, lead, dyes, or fragrances, which could further aggravate your baby’s skin conditions.
Comfort
Crib sheets should provide ample comfort for the baby during sleep time. You should always look for sheets with extra paddings, such as quilted designs or plush fabrics. Natural fibers like cotton or wool are great choices as they are soft and comfy against the baby’s skin. Also, make sure to read product reviews and look for products that many users claim to be extra comfy for their little ones.
Comparing the Top Fitted Crib Sheet of 2023
Natemia Fitted Crib Sheet – Best Overall
1
The Natemia Fitted Crib Sheet is made from 100% certified organic Turkish cotton, offering parents a natural, safe option for their little angels. This soft, light and breathable jersey knit fabric helps to promote comfortable sleep and avoid overheating to keep your baby comfy all night. The fitted sheet is designed to fit securely around the standard-sized crib and toddler mattresses, making it a versatile choice. It comes with an elastic band that wraps around the entire edge of the crib or mattress, and deep pockets keep the sheet in place for a snug fit to prevent wrinkles.
The shrink-resistant material makes cleaning it a breeze — all you have to do is toss this crib sheet into the washing machine to get it as good as new. The manufacturer promises a product that passes the test of time, so you can trust that this crib sheet will remain soft and comfortable for years to come. With its quality material, versatile sizing, and affordable price tag, this fitted crib sheet is our top pick.
Pros
- Doesn’t bleed colors after washing
- Elasticized edges for a secure fit
- Available in 22 color options
Cons
- A bit overpriced
Everyday Kids Fitted Crib Sheet – Most Affordable
2
The Everyday Kids Fitted Crib Sheet provides an ideal combination of comfort and style for any nursery. Its 100% soft, breathable microfiber fabric offers both comfort and breathability for your little one. The wide range of colors and patterns means you can mix and match with ease to create the perfect atmosphere for your little one. This sheet comes in a convenient two-pack and is affordably priced, making it perfect for every baby nursery.
The quality of this fitted crib sheet is notably high, as it has been crafted with care from durable, naturally hypoallergenic fabric. Each sheet has full elastic trim along four sides to ensure a safe and secure fit, and the 8-inch deep pockets make it compatible with any standard-sized crib or toddler mattress. The fabric is also fade-resistant, quick-drying, and easy to care for, so you can simply machine wash it with similar color clothes on a gentle cycle and tumble dry on low heat or line dry.
Pros
- Soft and breathable microfiber fabric
- Free from any harmful chemicals
- Easy to secure and use
Cons
- Colors may differ from pictures
Burt’s Bees Fitted Crib Sheet – Highest Quality
3
Whether you’re a parent or a caregiver looking for a safe and comfortable sleeping environment for your little one, look no further than the Burt’s Bees Baby Crib Sheet. This fitted crib sheet is made of 100% organic cotton, which is Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) certified to ensure the purity of the material. It also benefits from 360 premium elastic that provides extra stretch for a snugger fit. To add to this, an extra fabric overlaps on the bottom edge combined with the elastic works to prevent the sheet from creeping up on the mattress.
The dimensions of this crib sheet are the ideal size for most standard and toddler mattresses. The natural breathability of the cotton ensures that it won’t irritate your little one’s skin and never become uncomfortable, providing adequate temperature control throughout the night. With this product, parents can have peace of mind knowing that their baby is safe and secure while they are sleeping.
Pros
- Simple design matches any decor
- Stretchy material offers a snug fit
- Retains fit after washing
Cons
- Easily catches hair and fur
TILLYOU Fitted Crib Sheet – Most Breathable
4
With its soft, breathable, and comfortable material, the TILLYOU Fitted Crib Sheet is a practical and attractive choice for parents. The set includes two sheets with 8-inch deep pockets to securely fit standard crib and toddler mattresses, allowing you to create a safe and beautiful sleeping environment. The fabric of the sheets is smooth to the touch, making it comfortable and pleasant for your little one to sleep on. Plus, it’s also extremely breathable, so air can pass through easily to keep your baby cool and dry.
This fitted crib sheet is designed to be skin- and hair-friendly, with no wrinkle or satin surfaces remaining to ensure your tot’s maximum comfort. The full elastic band around the edges secures a snug fit that won’t slip away when your child is napping or sleeping on the sheet. With this product, you have the choice of different colors and patterns, so you can always give your child a new look for their crib bedding.
Pros
- Skin-friendly and safe material
- Thin enough to be breathable
- Durable elastic band on edges
Cons
- May pills after several washes
KeaBabies Fitted Crib Sheet – Most Comfortable
5
The KeaBabies Fitted Crib Sheet is an ideal bedding set for modern parents. This set includes two fitted crib sheets that fit standard nursery crib mattresses. Designed with versatility and convenience in mind, these sheets are made from 100% premium quality jersey cotton fabric, making them both breathable and comfortable for your little ones. The fabric is also suitable for sensitive skin, making it a great option for parents who want to keep their babies safe and cozy every night.
It also comes with the exclusive SnugFit Tech, which is an ingenious fabric knit that allows the fitted sheet to stretch when fitting it onto your baby’s mattress. The high-quality elastic bands are even intricately stitched so that the fitted crib sheet stays securely in place at all times. They are machine washable and dryer friendly, so cleaning them is a breeze. They are also designed to last, ensuring you have one less thing to worry about as a parent!
Pros
- Sewn-in elastic band for added durability
- Unique design and gender-neutral print
- Suitable for delicate and sensitive skin
Cons
- Not completely organic
People Also Asked
Q: How do I know if fitted crib sheets are safe for babies with allergies?
A: Most fitted crib sheets are hypoallergenic, which makes them ideal for babies with allergies or sensitivities to certain elements such as dust mites or pet dander. It’s important to check labels before purchasing any products to determine if they meet safety standards set by Oeko-Tex or GOTS.
Q: How often should I wash my baby’s fitted crib sheet?
A: It’s recommended that you wash your fitted crib sheet at least once a week to keep it clean and fresh for your baby’s delicate skin. But if there are any stains or spills, you should wash them or spot-clean them right away to prevent bacteria from growing in the fabric. These bacteria can be harmful to your baby’s health if left unchecked for too long.
Q: How do I care for my fitted crib sheet?
A: When washing your fitted crib sheet, it’s important to read any included care instructions before laundering the fabric so as not to damage the fabric or shrink it out of shape. You should use a mild detergent, cold water setting on your washing machine, and hang it out to air dry rather than tumble dry to prevent shrinkage. Additionally, there may be other instructions regarding specific treatments for unique fabrics, such as organic cotton or bamboo fabrics, which should always be followed carefully.
Q: How do I ensure the sheet stays on the mattress?
A: To ensure that your fitted sheet stays securely in place while your baby moves around in their sleep, look for one with extra straps or elastic edging on all sides. These features will ensure that the fitted crib mattress stays tucked in even if your little one twists and turns during their nap or nighttime sleep session.
Q: Are all fitted crib sheets machine-washable?
A: Most high-quality fitted crib sheets are machine-washable, making them easy to maintain and keep clean for maximum comfort for your little one throughout their sleep cycle. However, this may not be the case for some products. Be sure to follow the manufacturer’s instructions when laundering your fitted sheet to ensure its longevity over time!
Q: Are fitted crib sheets safe for babies?
A: Yes, fitted crib sheets are safe for babies when used correctly and with appropriate supervision. Make sure that the sheet fits snugly on the mattress without any extra material that could pose a suffocation hazard or cause the sheet to slip off while your baby is sleeping.
