We may earn a commission if you make a purchase through one of our links. The editorial staff was not involved in the creation of this content.
The Best Crib Sheets for Your Baby’s Skin
Last updated: 3 May 2023
Welcoming a new member to the family is equal parts exciting and overwhelming. Before your little one has their first day in this world, you must carefully prepare for their arrival. Be it a veteran mommy or a first-time dad, all parents find that nine months aren't enough time to get things ready. While you might get away with a little procrastination here and there, don't delay the essentials.
Needless to say, a crib is one of the most important things you'll buy. But don't forget about the sheets! Soft covers hit the spot. Newborns already have a reputation for waking up at night but when they aren't comfortable, it's much more frequent. With the smoothest crib sheets in 2023, your baby will have a better chance of a good night’s sleep.
Being bombarded by parenting advice? Wading through the onslaught of confusing recommendations can be nerve-wracking. From feeding methods to the right wall colors for your baby’s nursery, newbie parents have a ton to process. Naturally, not all advice is worth your consideration and some isn’t even asked for. Since you’re surfing the internet looking for a quality crib sheet, we’ve put together this buying guide to help you pick the very best on the market.
Factors That Make Crib Sheets Worth It
The right covers for your newborn’s mattress should be made of a soft and lightweight texture. While thicker sheets are tempting in that they partially protect against liquids from seeping through, don’t bother. Smooth cotton is the way to go! Or better yet, buy the organic variety instead. Both are super breathable and keep your baby’s sweat levels in check during the summer.
Deep pockets aren’t enough on their own. For crib sheets to truly remain in place, all edges should have elastic rims. Rest assured, scrunched hems are incredibly convenient — they’re great at preventing air pockets, wrinkles, and folds. So, when it comes to buying for newborns who love to toss and turn, nothing beats a secure sheet that refuses to budge.
The phrase ‘as soft as a baby’s bottom’ wasn’t coined for no reason. Texture is everything; unfortunately, even the most visually appealing crib sheets can feel extremely abrasive against the skin. This is usually because manufacturers sometimes add a stiffening agent to prevent wrinkling. And that’s the last thing you want!
Old-fashioned cotton gets the job done perfectly. Similarly, it’s best to stay away from sheets with embroidered patches. While they look great, they’re extremely discomforting and can trap germs. Don’t reach for those deceivingly attractive embroidered crib sheets on the shelves. You’ll wish you didn’t!
Keeping your baby’s surroundings clean isn’t just important, it’s necessary. Newborns are vulnerable to all sorts of bacteria and viruses. No parent wants to see their child sick, which is why cleaning their crib sheets ranks at the top of the list.
That said, buy fabric that’s too delicate and you’re forced to hand wash the covers. Machine washability and dryer friendliness should be a given. To check whether a product you like is safe for the washer, review the item details and sift through buyer feedback.
Are Organic Crib Sheets Worth the Price Tag?
Organic is no longer a word, it’s a phenomenon that’s taken over the world. A vast majority of people recognize the label in the context of food or skincare, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. If you’re wondering why organic crib sheets are a thing in the 21st century, brace yourself.
Cotton grown organically has drastically lesser pesticides when compared to the generic variety. Further, it’s much more eco-friendly due to lower water consumption as well as carbon dioxide emissions.
The only drawback? Organic crib sheets are pricier because they’re better for your baby. No matter how many times you wash their bedding, the chances of your newborn breathing in nasty chemicals cannot be eliminated with non-organic cotton.
Crib Sheets With or Without Padding
Padded crib sheets can add a buoyant feel to a hard mattress. So, if the crib mattress you own needs all the help it can get, it’s a good idea to invest in the padded types. But beware of the side effects of these sheets. Not only are padded crib sheets harder to clean, but they’re also prone to germ build-up. In the worst-case scenario, you’ll be dealing with smelly bedding that irritates your baby’s skin.
On the other hand, non-padded crib sheets don’t do much other than cover a mattress, but this isn’t a big deal. In general, your goal should be to buy a soft mattress instead of relying on padded sheets.
Flat Crib Sheets vs. Fitted Crib Sheets
Just like adult beds are either covered in flat or fitted sheets, cribs are no different. If you’re stuck between the two, go with fitted sheets, no questions asked.
A flat sheet tends to come loose and bunch up easily — you certainly don’t want to spend time tidying up your baby’s bed every other hour. Most importantly, flat crib sheets are fairly prone to wrinkles, which cause discomfort.
Why Crib Sheet Size Is So Important
One would think that a crib is the safest space for a baby. Unfortunately, it’s not! Cribs can quickly turn into a hazard when they’re covered in a sheet that’s too big. Although this doesn’t sound very believable, all it takes is a few twists to tangle a child in the folds. The only way to prevent this is by investing in premium quality sheets of the right size.
So, before you start shopping, measure your bassinet or crib. Then, check the product details to make sure the dimensions match. To top it off, look for deep pockets; this nifty feature is a godsend, especially for newbie parents who barely get any sleep!
Made of premium imported jersey cotton, Amazon Basics’ Fitted Crib Sheet is texture-free and smooth to the touch. It is finely knit to ensure the comfort of your newborn. Since it’s available in 11 different colors, parents can choose from a variety of muted tones for nursery beds.
Due to its unique composition, this crib sheet is slightly stretchable and can be changed easily. Although solid, it has a subtle heather effect that complements other baby accessories as well as nursery decor. The best part? This sheet is super durable, dryer safe, safe for the washing machine, and woven to meet eco-friendly guidelines. Because of its excellent quality, comfort, and various colors, we’ve chosen this crib sheet as the best on our list.
At 52 inches long and 28 inches wide, Tillyou’s Microfiber Crib Sheets feature a solid pattern to cover your baby’s bed in style. The fabric is breathable and lightweight, making it perfect for humid summer nights. To top it off, you don’t need to worry about roughness as the sheets are silky soft, and gently glide against your baby’s delicate skin.
Available in a variety of different colors, this pick easily fits with the look of your little one’s room. But, best of all is how easy maintaining and caring for these crib sheets is. With just a few spins in the washing machine, buyers can enjoy clean sheets without any manual hassle.
This high-quality crib sheet has elastic bands all around its 8-inch deep bed pockets, the latter of which limits air pockets and creases that make it uncomfortable to sleep on. Needless to say, Biloban is no stranger to quality. With sturdy seams and soft fabric, it makes sense to choose this product over others.
But that’s not all! This crib sheet is made of high-quality microfiber that offers ample breathability. You’ll also benefit from its washing machine and dryer-friendly design that helps limit any manual grunt work. Additionally, the product is pre-shrunk and environmentally sustainable.
Not a fan of flimsy cotton sheets? Everyday Kid’s sheets flaunt a smooth polyester microfiber composition to withstand tugging and tears. They are breathable, compact, and secured at the seams, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg.
Not only are the sheets machine washable, but they’re also fade-resistant — even regular drying won’t degrade the color easily. Meanwhile, 8-inch deep pockets and elastic trims are added on each side to ensure a snug fit. But, in case you’re not happy with the product, you can request a refund through the seller’s 30-day money-back guarantee.
Ditch synthetics and shift to organic cotton with Burt’s Bees Fitted Crib Sheets. This product leverages 360-degree technology for a super stretchable elastic band that provides a snug fit. At 52 inches long and 28 inches wide, this crib sheet effortlessly adorns a standard crib.
Unlike others on this list, this crib sheet comes in various patterned prints. Extra fabric is also added to create overlapped edges that prevent air pockets and creases. Plus, the sheets are made of 100% GOTS-certified cotton that enables maximum breathability and gently caresses your baby’s soft skin.
Q: How do I remove an oil stain from my baby’s crib sheets?
A: For stubborn oil stains, use gentle dish soap and water to coat the affected area. Then, rub the fabric to ‘loosen’ oil particles from sheet fibers and toss it in the washing machine.
Q: Are dark-colored crib sheets prone to fading?
A: Not all crib sheets will shed color, however, some manufacturers use cheap dyes which leads to quick fading. To stay on the safe side, choose lighter shades of your favorite colors.
Q: My dog has various allergies. Can I use a regular crib sheet for its bed?
A: Yes. As long as there aren't any triggering fragrances or fabric stiffening agents, crib sheets are pretty safe for all pets. Regardless, you may want to wash the covers upon receiving them for the first time.
The Mighty Moms Reviews Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you tackle motherhood and everything that comes along with it. The content is created by The Mighty Moms Reviews Team. Mighty Moms’ editorial staff is not involved. Mighty Moms is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.